Hailee Steinfeld’s Mattie Ross is taking the ‘Best breakout performance of 2010’ award away from Chloe Moretz’s Hit-Girl in Kick-Ass. There, I said it. Outside of acting there is a lot to praise True Grit on, it is beautify shot, surprisingly funny, well paced, involving, and it manages to be a lot of fun while having some depth, with that said, the only disappointment is the narrative itself, an issue that didn’t really come into effect until about half way into the movie.
Mattie Ross is off to find the man who is responsible for her father’s death Tom Chaney (Josh Brolin), of course she can’t get him herself, she’s only fourteen. So she recruits the meanest U.S. marshal she can find Rooster Cogburn (Jeff Bridges) and then happens to meet LaBoeuf (Matt Damon) a man who will never let you forget that he is a Texas Ranger and just happens to already be looking for Chaney for another crime he committed. So after some very hilarious scenes young Ross manages to get LaBoeuf and Cogburn to go after Chaney and she even manages to get a horse of her own so she could go along with them. After all of that wonderful build up, you know you’re in for a ride … oh wait.
Here’s where the film drops in quality for me, the trip divulges into an on and off again relationship between Cogburn and LaBeouf, one minute LaBeouf gives up, then he’s back, then he quits again, then he’s back. It’s made up for slightly due to little interactions between Cogburn, Ross, and LaBoeuf when they are getting along and discover that Chaney is riding along with a group. And when they finally make it to Chaney, wow, what a let down. I get that Chaney isn’t supposed to be the toughest person given the unflattering description he’s given by most people and Brolin plays him fit to that description. But its like ‘this is the guy you were going after?’ why not make it the leader of the gang he’s riding around with. As a character, Chaney is effective in almost no way whatsoever. I’m having a hard time believing that he did anything that they say he did. The character does eventually link you to a stellar climax featuring other and more interesting villains. And then comes an ending that probably would have been better if the last five minutes were cut, they weren’t bad, but they felt a bit excessive.
Now with all of that said, its still one of the better movies of the year. I wouldn’t describe the narrative as bad, it’s just for all of that great build up, the end result just ends up being a bit disappointing. The cast still shines through. The accents, the costumes, and the production design are all authentic. And it still retains quality that would only come from the Coen’s brothers.
Come Oscar season it’ll probably be appreciated more for its acting and technical achievements, but that’s a no go on ‘Best Picture’ and ‘Best Director’. The Coen’s still did the book justice and it’s not a bad way to introduce younger audiences not willing to sit through the 1969 True Grit to the story.
Final Score: 3/4